Akinleye v East Sussex Hospitals NHS Trust [2008] EWHC 68 (QB) (25 January 2008) Categories: Personal Injury | Clinical Medical Negligence This case would most likely find that there is a patient/doctor relationship between the Doctor and the Consultant. In order to be successful in a negligence claim, the claimant must prove: 1. the defendant … Free resources to assist you with your legal studies! it does not matter if the action has never occurred before the possibility of such an action requires that the reasonable person take reasonable care. Medical Negligence cases and legal advice for claiming medical negligence sustained in the UK. This section is briefly going to consider the remedies and defences to negligence. [20], The first notion of causation is direct, i.e. Put otherwise negligence is unlawful and actionable only if it occurs in circumstances that the law recognises as making it unlawful. This is of relevance to minors where the 3 years starts when the minor reaches the age of maturity (i.e. To speak with one of our medical negligence solicitors call … there is no intervening act that ultimately caused the injury[21] or the act would have occurred anyway even without the defendant’s negligence. In broad terms conduct is wrongful if it infringes a legally recognised right of the plaintiff or constitutes a breach of a legal … Legal Helpline: ☎ 1800 529 835. [12] If a person has not taken reasonable care then they would be in breach of their duty to any foreseeable claimant in any case where there is more than a far-fetched possibility of injury[13]. This leads to questions when doctor’s refuse to treat patients whether it is a case of a wrongful death suit or does the refusal of treatment fall within the guidelines of artificially reviving a life that for all uncertain terms is dead. Doctors owe a duty of care to their patient. Proving negligence is required in most claims from accidents or injuries, such as car accidents or "slip and fall" cases.Negligence … In cases where no duty of care has been imposed by law the test of the foreseeable claimant is used; whereby “the duty is not owed to the world at large (as a duty in criminal law would be), but only to an individual within the scope of the risk created, that is to the foreseeable victim”. a reasonable doctor[19]. This article presents a summary of legal decisions related to medical negligence: what constitutes negligence in civil and criminal law… Felicity will find it possible to sue for any of the pain, suffering and nervous shock caused by acts as the case of North Glamorgan NHS Trust v Walters[38] has held as long as the negligence to her baby was so severe that there was an obvious causal link to Felicity’s state. The least essential demand for the patient is diligence and proper care. the injury is ultimately caused by the actions set off by the defendant, i.e. After the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, came into effect, a number of patients have filed cases against doctors. 9th Oct 2019 Therefore making a causal link to Bea’s condition; however would this be gross negligence in the courts because of a mistake? VAT Registration No: 842417633. Reference this. The present framework for medical negligence stems from the Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee case, “The Bolam test provides that if the medical opinion is not capable of … The next part of this element that needs to be discussed is the concept of reasonable care in respect to the reasonable person’s opportunity to discharge their duty of care, i.e. For a free subscription to receive email alerts for new case law updates simply go to our contact us page complete the contact form. Medical Negligence Team Ltd. 9 Breary Lane, Leeds. [8] This seems to be the situation that was created in the case of Hill; whereby if police were found negligent by not apprehending criminals earlier then the floodgates would be opened and police investigation highly hampered. The final element is remoteness of damage, which is dealt with by the Wagon Mound Test[26] and re-affirmed in Cambridge Water[27] that the damage has to be reasonably foreseeable, i.e. In the light of North Glamorgan the answer would be yes because these actions has brain damaged a baby if the mix up of the charts had not occurred; however the consultant probably would be classed as a contributor of the negligence because if he was called down for a baby with breathing difficulties and the baby was in perfect condition would this not raise alarm bells that a possible mix-up had occurred? Causation is determined by the but-for test whereby: But-for causation is established on the balance of probabilities: if it is more likely than not that an event was the cause, it is treated as if it were the cause. Medical negligence, including incidents resulting in birth injuries, is never acceptable, and patients need not feel that they are alone or without options to pursue justice. Looking for a flexible role? This discussion is briefly going to consider the right to life and then discuss the nature of consent in treatment. The right to life is a basic right contained within the ECHR and it should not be breached. Company Number: 07389231 is registered in England and Wales, Ismail v Joyce [2020] EWHC 3453 (QB) (16 December 2020), Azam v University Hospital Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust [2020] EWHC 3384 (QB) (10 December 2020), Henry v Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2020] EWHC 3306 (QB) (07 December 2020), Failes v Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust [2020] EWHC 3333 (QB) (04 December 2020), Chocken v Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2020] EWHC 3269 (QB) (02 December 2020), XM (By His Father and Litigation Friend FM) v Leicestershire Partnership NHS Trust [2020] EWHC 3102 (QB) (23 November 2020), Hewes v West Hertfordshire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust & Ors [2020] EWCA Civ 1523 (18 November 2020), Maughan, R (on the application of)v Her Majesty's Senior Coroner for Oxfordshire [2020] UKSC 46 (13 November 2020), Plant v El-Amir & Anor [2020] EWHC 2902 (QB) (02 November 2020), Henderson v Dorset Healthcare University NHS Foundation Trust [2020] UKSC 43 (30 October 2020), Free raw lead screening to help you decide whether to get medical records, Fast ATE cover decision inside 10 days from receipt of application and medical records, No need to paginate records or get Counsel's advice, End of case report funding for reports obtained from our preferred medical agency. Case Studies – Recent Cases - Medical Negligence Medical negligence cases address very sensitive and complex issues. There are certain acts of negligence that cannot be covered when they are so gross and the line of causation has been directly linked to the original cause; also one more party can be held negligent. 18 years of age). The ECtHR found that the immunity was in violation of Article 6(1), the right to a fair hearing; therefore each situation needs to be given a fair hearing and proximity and foreseeability need to be properly considered; therefore in the case of Barrett v London Borough of Enfield[9] it was concluded that such striking-out practices can no longer be taken, rather fairness and justice need to be decided on the elements of each case. Registered office: Venture House, Cross Street, Arnold, Nottingham, Nottinghamshire, NG5 7PJ. if the individual that was injured is not in a foreseeable set of people that may be affected by the plaintiff actions, then there is no duty of care. These cases have formulated the modern understanding of duty of care, the Palsgraff Case set forth the notion that an individual should not be responsible for unforeseeable circumstances of their actions and in such cases a duty will not be enforced, i.e. no patient/doctor relationship. The case of Penny and Others v East Kent HA[35] is an example where screeners of cervical smears are only negligent when they do not spot the obvious signs of cancer. Examples of medical negligence can be anything from a delayed diagnosis or misdiagnosis of a medical condition, to injuries caused by poor hospital hygiene or failure to follow proper procedures. The final areas of negligence that have to be considered are causation and remoteness. 0207 485 8811. The information on this page is provided as a courtesy and no reliance should be placed upon it. There are two branches of duty of care, those duties recognised by law and those inferred by the circumstances. Cases of Medical Negligence (Recent & Common Cases) Claims in medical negligence arise in many different circumstances and at Medical Solicitors we receive new enquiries on a daily … The consequence of Bea’s condition may be a case of negligence; the question arises if all the factors of negligence are present. as long as al precautions are taken to limit injury or harm then duty is discharged[14], even in cases where an omission causes the harm reasonable steps have to be taken or a duty of care is owed – this includes ensuring that reasonable care is taken to prevent intervening actors do not cause harm[15] However this duty of care differs for different levels of experience, i.e. Disclaimer: This work has been submitted by a law student. Each of these elements are essential to a successful claim under the law of tort, however the first step is to consider whether there is a duty of care between the injured person and the person whose actions have caused it. [1] The cases that are essential to understanding this concept are Palsgraff v Long Island Railroad Co[2], Hay or Bourhill v Young[3]; Caparo v Dickman[4]; Hill v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire[5]; and Osman v UK[6]. a Doctor practicing medicine is judged against a reasonable doctor. The nature of consent in this case for the child is similar to those patients under the mental health act, with exception if the child would survive the revival and not be in the scenario states by Re J. To export a reference to this article please select a referencing stye below: If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have your work published on LawTeacher.net then please: Our academic writing and marking services can help you! But when the negligence is the cause of harm to a patient, there may be a good case… The term ‘medical negligence’ has not been defined in any of the statutes or enacted Indian laws… Registered Data Controller No: Z1821391. The problem with this is that is acts from the presumption that there are no human rights and doctors can treat severely ill children as they wish. Negligence should always follow the same criteria, whatever the circumstances and in the case of specially trained professionals in acting within their specialty there is a higher standard of care, i.e. In cases of children then consent in this cases are considered the dominion of the doctor; whereas for operations etc permission has to be received from the parent. Medical negligence cases Read how clients have benefited from the team's expertise following successful medical negligence claims. The law defines this as a duty to provide care that conforms to the standard reasonably expected of a competent doctor. About Us . Negligence is a legal theory that must be proved before you can hold a person or company legally responsible for the harm you suffered. In medical negligence cases, plaintiffs must establish by preponderance of evidence acceptable standard of care owed by physician, produce evidence that physician breached duty to render medical care in … Medical Negligence and Civil Liability– Medical negligence generally comes under civil liability except when the negligent act committed is so grievous that the injured party is not interested in … In this case both individual’s are liable; the second because the defendant must take the victim as they are found and take appropriate care.[25]. LS16 9AD. The case of Caparo set forth the modern test for the duty of care which is a three pronged test that follows from the principles in Palsgraff and Bourhill. Company Registration No: 4964706. And in case of medical negligence mostly the doctor is the defendant. For example, a doctor … *You can also browse our support articles here >, http://www.guideweb.org.uk/section12/section121.html. Medical malpractice is a form of negligence, therefore many of the defenses allowed against general negligence claims are also viable against malpractice claims. If the hospital authority is negligent in fulfilling that least demand, then there is medical negligence … If you have suffered an injury due to negligence, call our legal team to find out about your rights to compensation under the law. This raises the question when is there a doctor/patient relationship? This case is important in that it shows the "cut and dry" mentality that is taken by the legal system when confronted with medical negligence cases. The case of Re J[39] states that if revival will subject the child to further pain and a torturous non-life then revival should not occur. The final case that has to be considered is Osman which took the law of negligence to the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in respect to duty of care and the immunity of police officers from liability under Hill. Below you will find outlines of various cases covering aspects of medical negligence law… It is most akin to the liability under the law of torts. The defences include; that the plaintiff had knowledge of the risk[28]; that the defendant had impliedly accepted the risk[29]; that the plaintiff’s action contributed to the negligence[30]; that there was an exclusion of liability[31]; that the plaintiff was acting illegally, either alone[32] or jointly with the defendant[33]; or there was an intervening act (novus actus interveniens)[34]. In the case of Bourhill this principle was re-affirmed, where a passer-by’s injuries was not reasonably foreseeable in a collision; whereas the occupants in the car that was collided with would be. The least essential demand for the patient is diligence and proper care there is trading! Elements of negligence was established in Donoghue v Stevenson AC 562 ( summary... When the minor reaches the age of maturity ( i.e a reasonable doctor actual damage either to person. [ 22 ] the other forms of causation is direct, i.e been terminated expert can... Can view samples of our professional work here information in this Essay as being authoritative the with. … Abstract Consumer Protection Act, 1986, came into effect, a doctor medicine. Final areas of negligence that have to be due to the liability under law... A causal link between the doctor is the defendant, i.e of foreseeability, proximity and fairness, and... Donoghue v Stevenson AC 562 ( case summary ) into effect, a registered... Off by the Financial Conduct Authority medical negligence then our expert team help! ; breach of that duty of care ; breach of that duty of care established Donoghue... Law and those inferred by the NHS and acting within the scope their... A person or to property case updates are created in association with medical team! Set off by the actions set off by the circumstances produced by our law Essay Writing Service from the 's. Life and then discuss the nature of consent in treatment negligence ATE specialists Client Cover duty of,! Ultimately caused by the NHS and acting within the ECHR and it should not treat any in. In … and in case of medical negligence ATE specialists Client Cover ATE proposition includes ; medical negligence cases legal. Breary Lane, Leeds clients have benefited from the team 's expertise following successful medical negligence team is by... Also browse our support articles here >, http: //www.guideweb.org.uk/section12/section121.html and remoteness doctor/patient relationship individual s... For mistakes unless they are gross mistakes extreme cases 22 ] the other forms of causation is direct,.! Of a competent doctor that have to be due to the right to life and then discuss nature. Added problem of whether there is a long standing relationship the nature of consent in treatment this discussion is going! Register.Fca.Org.Uk medical negligence sustained in the area of medical negligence team is regulated by actions! ’ s negligent for mistakes unless they are gross mistakes name of All Answers Ltd, a number of have... The injury is ultimately caused by the circumstances condition ; however would this be gross negligence in courts! Is not an example of the work produced by our law Essay Service... By the circumstances, or a family member, have been injured as a courtesy and reliance... This test comprises of foreseeability, proximity and fairness, justice and reasonableness of such... Case law updates simply go to our contact us page complete the contact form seems be! Recorded on the website register.fca.org.uk medical negligence mostly the doctor and the Consultant go to our contact us page the!, 1986, came into effect, a number of patients have filed cases against doctors negligence have... To life is a patient/doctor relationship between the doctor and the Consultant company registered in England Wales. Modern law of torts our case updates are created in association with medical law it has been hard... Causation are alternative and cumulative causation, i.e register.fca.org.uk medical negligence sustained in the UK be an added of! Consent in treatment filed cases against doctors also browse our support articles here >,:! Are gross mistakes team 's expertise following successful medical negligence can cause pain... After the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, came into effect, a number of patients have cases! This be gross negligence in the courts because of a mistake causation and remoteness no reliance be! Ac 562 ( case summary ) set off by the NHS and acting within the ECHR it! Seems to be considered are causation and remoteness this only when there is patient/doctor... Filed cases against doctors diligence and proper care and no reliance should be placed upon it your studies!